How do you limit output?

The hows and whys of running sound.
Post Reply
Message
Author
Frederic Gelinas
Posts: 566
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2008 10:03 am
Location: Saint-Pie, Quebec, Canada

How do you limit output?

#1 Post by Frederic Gelinas »

I read everywhere that you should limit your amp output in order to preserve your cab's health. It makes sense to me. What do I need and how would I setup if I want to limit the signal going to the cab? Is the procedure the same for tops and subs?
Frédéric Gélinas, HF Audio
Authorized Builder
HFAudio.ca
Free tone Generator
Saint-Hyacinthe, Québec, Canada

User avatar
Zack Brock
Posts: 1124
Joined: Sun Oct 07, 2007 1:06 am
Location: Northeast Florida
Contact:

Re: How do you limit output?

#2 Post by Zack Brock »

You obtain a brickwall limiter which is a piece of rack mount equipment that allows you to limit the input voltage to the amplifier. Or you buy an amp like a Crown XTI that contains a built in DSP which includes a limiter, or a dbx DriveRack or Behringer Ultradrive or any similar multi-function unit that contains a brickwall (not just a hard knee compressor) limiter that you can configure.

Here is a good step-by-step on how to set your limiter settings, not sure I remember where I got this from but it was from another user here on the forums in an old thread:
Limiter Settings & dBu Calculations
--

You can calculate the maximum power available to the drivers and set
your limiters accordingly.

First you need to convert the power rating of your driver to Volts
rather than watts.

Lets assume you have a driver rated for 600 watts at 8 ohms nominal.
The formula would be....

Sqrt(watts*ohms) so sqrt(600*8) = 69.28 volts

Next you need to convert the volts to dBu using the formula 20 Log(volts/.775)

so 20 Log(69.28/.775) = 39.03 dBu

Now lets assume you have an amplifier capable of 800 watts at 8 ohms.
We now need to figure out mow much gain the amplifier has using the
first formula.

sqrt(800*8) = 80 volts. then we convert that to dBu also.
20 Log (80/.775) = 40.28 dBu

Now to find the limiter setting you subtract the amplifier gain from
the dBu required from the driver.

39.03-40.28 = -1.25 dBu

So you would set your limiter for 1.25dBu below full output of your amplifier.

So if your amplifier has full output at +4dBu then you would set your
limiter for +2.75dBu.

Now If your amplifier has a constant gain such as 26 dB or 32 dB gain
then you would subtract the gain of the amp from the driver dBu

So for 26 dB gain the math would be
39.03-26 = 13.03 dBu for the limiter

Or for 32 dBu then it would be
39.03-32 = 7.03 dBu for the limiter.

All of these answers would give you ~600 watts to the driver depending
on your particular amps settings. There you go, now your are a little
safer.
Zack Brock
Authorized Builder, Northeast Florida (Greater Jacksonville Area)
WavePulse Acoustics | zackbrock@macpulse.com | http://www.bestbasscabs.com/

schadstr
Posts: 24
Joined: Thu Sep 23, 2010 2:29 pm
Location: central NJ

Re: How do you limit output?

#3 Post by schadstr »

hey guys, zack these formulas shuld also help me with setting up the limiter on my drpa+ also?
2 T24's
4 sl36
4 jbl eons
2 QSC K12
2 Crown macroteck 2400
1 crown xls900
1 drpa+ just added
denon 3700
denonmixer
serato sl
bbe sonic maximizer

User avatar
Zack Brock
Posts: 1124
Joined: Sun Oct 07, 2007 1:06 am
Location: Northeast Florida
Contact:

Re: How do you limit output?

#4 Post by Zack Brock »

schadstr wrote:hey guys, zack these formulas shuld also help me with setting up the limiter on my drpa+ also?
Yes but I don't think the DRPA+ is a brickwall limiter (the original DRPA was not, not sure about the +)
Zack Brock
Authorized Builder, Northeast Florida (Greater Jacksonville Area)
WavePulse Acoustics | zackbrock@macpulse.com | http://www.bestbasscabs.com/

Ron K
Posts: 1569
Joined: Sun Jun 17, 2007 12:08 pm
Location: North East Pa.
Contact:

Re: How do you limit output?

#5 Post by Ron K »

I just keep the level under control by listening for cone breakup, coil knocking or any distortion that doesn't sound right. Using proper gain structure and amp matching the loads doesn't hurt any either.

It helps when you know where the real limits are in your rig and then you dont exceed them.If you cant do proper gain structure or amp to load matching then you should use a limiter to stay on the safe side.

Edit: Limiters in the Crown XTIs are not peak limiters but RMS feedback limiters. They are "not" brickwall limiters and not peak stop limiters!
Ever since I replaced sex with food I cant even get into my own pants!

User avatar
Zack Brock
Posts: 1124
Joined: Sun Oct 07, 2007 1:06 am
Location: Northeast Florida
Contact:

Re: How do you limit output?

#6 Post by Zack Brock »

Good points Ron, except you can't hear cone breakup in a folded horn subwoofer :(
Zack Brock
Authorized Builder, Northeast Florida (Greater Jacksonville Area)
WavePulse Acoustics | zackbrock@macpulse.com | http://www.bestbasscabs.com/

Greg Plouvier
Posts: 721
Joined: Mon Dec 03, 2007 12:47 pm
Location: High Desert of Colorado - Licensed builder
Contact:

Re: How do you limit output?

#7 Post by Greg Plouvier »

Zack Brock wrote:Good points Ron, except you can't hear cone breakup in a folded horn subwoofer :(
Actually you can but a few seconds later magic smoke is released.
Greg Plouvier
http://www.magnumcaseworks.com
Protective casing, speaker cabinets, Colorado BF builder, A/V installation, sales, live sound

el_ingeniero
Posts: 931
Joined: Sun Jul 18, 2010 11:46 pm
Location: Minneapolis, MN

Re: How do you limit output?

#8 Post by el_ingeniero »

Just remember to use the displacement limited voltage (volts required to send the driver cone to Xmax), if that is less than the voltage for the power rating.

Gregory East
Posts: 3495
Joined: Sat May 13, 2006 9:56 pm

Re: How do you limit output?

#9 Post by Gregory East »

That's the limit voltage that is specified in the plans for the recommended drivers for all the bass horns. It is frequently a lot less than the voltage you would put in to produce rated driver power in a radiator cab.

Post Reply