Bruce Weldy wrote: ↑Sat Feb 19, 2022 9:31 am
Seth wrote: ↑Fri Feb 18, 2022 11:11 pm
Fs 49.8
Qts 0.47
5.72 Xmax
Pro Driver
In Stock
$90
Cheap, but lousy xmax for a sub. That's gonna' limit the power you can put to 'em. I'm a proponent of putting the best driver you can in subs that balances price and output. Just doesn't make sense to have to build two of 'em to get the output of one if you'd only used a better driver to start with.
Gonna treat that as a Devils Advocate response (which it is) and Devils Advocate your Devils Advocate

...
Cheap, but lousy xmax for a sub.
I don't agree. "Lousy" is a judgement that's unfair in my opinion. It costs less and has more Xmax than the least expensive recommended driver in the plans. Perhaps Bill should change the recommendation to nothing less than the most you can get (or can't get, as the case seems to be)? (Playful satire. But, satire none-the-less)
I'm a proponent of putting the best driver you can in subs that balances price and output.
I am too. But, let's not ignore everything else, such as availability. The 3012LF isn't currently available. Given that, what's
your choice driver? Seems ridiculous to argue in favor of an option that doesn't exist at the moment. What is the best driver you can get that balances price and output at this moment in time? Given the two, would you be in favor the (not pro audio, 4Ω) $200+ Dayton Audio RSS315HF-4 he originally mentioned, over the (pro, 8Ω) $90 PRV? Maybe a different option that hasn't been mentioned?
Just doesn't make sense to have to build two of 'em to get the output of one if you'd only used a better driver to start with.
IMO, this really, truly, honestly depends on the specific goals and requirements of the end user and their intended use. In reality, two cabs with half the power each will outperform one cab with twice the power
every single time, every day of the week. If transport considerations rule out 2 cabs as an option, there's little point in considering the difference. However, if transport isn't a limiting consideration, two cabs (at roughly the same cost as one) absolutely makes more sense. Two cabs loaded with the driver I mentioned
will outperform one 3012LF loaded cab.
Just doesn't make sense to have to build two of 'em to get the output of one if you'd only used a better driver to start with.
So, realistically,... out of drivers that are currently available, what would you choose and recommend?