Bill Fitzmaurice wrote:Rune Bivrin wrote:
Speakers don't clip.
They do. A driver pushed past xmax reacts almost identically to an amp pushed past the rail voltage capacity. Guitar drivers are specifically designed to reach xmax at a very low percentage of Pe, so that they'll clip easily. They do so at as little as 5% of the Pe rating, so that there's plenty of room to push them hard without overheating the coil. Electric bass and PA woofers OTOH generally reach xmax at 40% or more of Pe; the Kappalites can reach 100% of Pe without exceeding xmax if properly loaded. That leaves far less margin for error between when you can hear them clipping and voice coil failure, making limiting a necessity. And of course in a folded horn you can't hear them clipping at all.
Well, yeah, I suppose so. Although I'd say in most of the cases we're interested in, a clipping driver is a driver on the way to driver heaven.
Guitar drivers are really a weird lot; more or less intentionally with low x-max, funky break-up modes and decidedly non-flat response. These days, that is. I'm sure they are built like that on purpose today because that's how we expect electric guitar to sound. Way back it was probably a result of trading quality for price and efficiency.
Kudos for reading the thread thoroughly; my comment was made nine months ago.

I often wish posters would review the entire thread before chiming in. Not so much here, but on TalkBass most definitely.